Tanzanite Color - How it Affects Value

Judging Tanzanite Color can be a confusing undertaking, especially online. This article will demonstrate Tanzanite color qualities in straightforward terms without the jargon.

Antony Zagoritis

GIA Graduate Gemologist
ICA Ambassador to Kenya

  • The adage “color is king” applies to Tanzanite, just as it does to all colored gemstones. It is the single most important value factor. When talking about Ruby, you hear descriptions like “pigeon’s blood red” to describe the deepest, most valuable colors and with Sapphire you hear “cornflower blue” to describe the finest Sapphire colors, generally from the ancient Kashmir deposit.

    Tanzanite is no different and color plays a large part in any grading exercise. The rules of color generally follow the laws of nature in that strong, vivid colors are attractors. Humans, for centuries have gravitated towards the deepest colors in gemstones, it is part of our psyche. This has been translated into a value system for gemstones, Tanzanite included, whereby the most vivid and deeply saturated colors are more highly coveted.

    Color – What to look for in the Finest Grade

    Whilst color grading systems can appear very complicated and technical, I am not going to go into actual grading systems in this article. Grading systems can confuse the issue as there are so many approaches these days notwithstanding the many invented ones that are prevalent on the web now where it seems that the more plus (+) signs you add to a made up grade or the more A's, the more accurate the grade! We have a separate article which goes into grading systems in depth if you want to learn more about those  - Tanzanite Color Grading Systems Article.

    Without the smoke and mirrors of grading systems, the mechanics of color are actually very simple and for the purposes of this article we will not go into technical details as these have been covered separately in the above article. We will simply explore what it is you need to be looking for in a fine Tanzanite in terms of color, look at some videos and a color chart and this should be a good grounding in getting you to a knowledgeable position on Tanzanite color.

    Color Saturations and how they Relate to Rarity

    Saturation is basically the depth of color in a stone, in essence the level to which color “fills” the stone. The more saturated a color is in a Tanzanite, the more valuable. This is not only because humans generally gravitate towards the more vivid colors but also because they occur much more rarely in nature. In fact, in the very finest 1% grades, very few carats are mined a year. The video below shows what these very fine stones look like.

    Video of Fine Tanzanite Colors. Tanzanites from our Investment Collection

    As you will see from the video, these stones have a very vivid, extremely intense color. This is because their color saturations are very high.  As this color saturation drops and the stones lose the intensity of the color, the grade drops in tandem.

    Take a look at this simple chart below to see how as saturation decreases, so does the grade.

    Color Saturation in Tanzanite.jpg

    In terms of rarity, the very fine colors shown in the video represent less than 1% of Tanzanite production. Miners used to use the term AAA to describe these pieces but honestly, this term seems to have lost most of its meaning as a quick search online will show you a huge quantity of sellers all calling their merchandise AAA, AAAA or adding a profusion of plus (+) marks to them to make them more marketable despite the fact that the color is clearly nowhere near the finest grades.

    The fact is, these top colors are very rare and do not occur in large quantities. Most sellers are selling stones in the B, A or AA grades and spike the images to improve the appearance. A video is a much better medium in which to judge color as it displays color more fully without interference you can see the stone from different angles and judge it in a more objective manner.

    Tone and its Part in Tanzanite Color

    Tone also plays a part. Tone is covered more deeply in our article on Tanzanite Grading systems under the GIA grading system section as this system is the more advanced and looks at all facets of color. However for the purposes of this article, a good description of Tone is the lightness to darkness of a stone.

    This is not actually describing the color saturation itself but rather overall tone and the light extinction within the stone. Bad cuts can play a part here as bulged pavilions (backs) cut to maximize weight can increase tone and make a stone look dark to an untrained eye so be aware of the role of cut  (our article on Tanzanite Cut is very informative on this subject).

    Always examine the areas where light reflects within a stone and examine it for its true color rather than being blinded by dark areas caused by light extinction. A stone that is dark because of overly high levels of tone is not the same as a Tanzanite that is highly saturated. In fact you can get very dark looking Tanzanites with high tone levels which have low color saturations. These are certainly not top grade pieces. If you look at this chart you will see how this works.
    Tanzanite Color intensity chart.jpg

    You can see how a Tanzanite can look dark with low saturation levels but high tone levels. This is not the same as top grade stones which have optimal mixes of tone and saturation. The very finest grade shown demonstrates how intense saturation can go. 

    The Role of Trichroism in Tanzanite Color

    Any discussion of color would not be complete without a mention of trichroism. Tanzanite is not a simple stone in any respect but when it comes to color, it has a kicker – it is trichroic. Trichroism is a gemologist’s term which means that as light passes through a mineral it vibrates in different planes. This causes the stone to exhibit a different color depending on which axis you are looking at it from. This phenomenon makes Tanzanite very reactive to the light source under which it is viewed. Whereas trichroism does not impact on Tanzanite's grade or value, it is an inherent part of Tanzanite's color so we thought it important to touch on the subject here. This article Trichroism and Red Flash in Tanzanite goes into some depth on this.

    Putting it All Together

    Tanzanite value, as with all colored gems, is largely linked to its color. The deepest, most vivid colors are also the most rarely occurring in nature. Online, this is not the case with almost every seller branding their goods as the best you can find, and some selling at very low prices. Bear in mind that the finest Tanzanites are mined very rarely and the miners demand top dollar for them, they know the value of the few crystals of this grade they mine annually. They are not widely available, nor do they go cheap. The old adage, “…if the price is too good, then what is wrong?” should spring to mind.

    Approach your assessment of color simply – Examine saturation levels and tone levels. The best medium to look at color is a video.  If there is a video, examine the color closely and watch the saturation levels in a stone. Keep an eye out for light extinction due to bad cutting. 

    This series of GIA Gemologist written articles on Tanzanite is provided to create a greater understanding of Tanzanite value and quality in the face of increased misinformation on the internet today. 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR Antony Zagoritis, Bsc, GG

Antony completed his GG (Graduate Gemologist) in 1998 at the Gemological Institute of America in California after a degree a Business at the University of Bath, in England. He has extensive experience in the colored gemstone trade with over 20 years buying rough at the source. He is currently the Ambassador to Kenya for the ICA (International Colored Gemstone Association) in New York which is the worldwide body for colored gemstones.

Latest Articles

African Rubies The Main Sources and How They Are Mined

Some of the world's finest and rarest Rubies are now mined in Africa. The traditional sources in Asia have been depleted and there's a new kid on the block. This article delves into the fascinating world of African Rubies, where and how they are mined.

Tanzanite Prices & Value - For 2024 and A Historical Perspective

Looking to find out what the prices are in the market in 2024? Or perhaps you'd like to understand price trajectory since the 1990's? This article will bring you up to date.

The Definitive Tsavorite Buying Guide

As with all gemstones, Tsavorite quality is defined by a number of factors. This article looks at these in detail and tells you all you need to know about grading Tsavorite quality, understanding Tsavorite prices, synthetics, investment potential and more

Tanzanite Mining – Large Scale or Small Scale and the “Ethical” Debate

There is a great deal of misinformation currently online regarding what "ethical" Tanzanite mining is. This article explores the different opinions.